|
|
|
|
 |
|
From
Dr. Robert Ackman
World-Renowned Expert on Fish and Seal
Oils
As early as 1960, a doctor in Halifax,
Nova Scotia gave seal oil to his patients
to improve their blood lipids. He did
not know at the time about the good health
of the Arctic Eskimos who ate a diet rich
in seal meat and oil, and as it was later
discovered, seldom suffered heart attacks.
The publicity of this discovery, in 1979-80,
indicated that the Eskimo benefited from
the three long chain Omega-3 Fatty Acids,
commonly known as EPA, DHA and DPA.
In the late 1970s, a group of Danish researchers examined the traditional diet of the Greenland Eskimo to find out why they had such a low incidence of cardiovascular disease, despite the fact that their diet had a high fat content. This study marked the beginning of a common health claim - that oils from fish and marine mammals can play a major role in preventing heart disease.
More people now identify a difference between types of fat; polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFA) are often referred to now as "good fat." In particular, n-3 fatty acids (better known as omega-3), found in oily fish such as salmon, are becoming widely known as having specific health benefits, including reducing the incidence of fatal cardiac arrhythmias. These fatty acids are also found in high concentrations in the oils of seal and whaleÑstaples of the Eskimo diet. The Danish researchers presumed these were responsible for their low rate of cardiovascular disease.
Dr. Mary Murphy is an Associate Professor of Physiology and Biophysics. She has long known about the cardiovascular benefits of dietary n-3 PUFA, but says there are still many unanswered questions. So, along with Dr. Robert Ackman and Anne Timmins of DalTech's Canadian Institute of Fisheries Technology, Med 1 student Joyce Scott-Coles, and Physiology and Biophysics colleagues Valerie Wright and Dr. Magda Horackova, Dr. Murphy embarked on a study to try to find some of these answers.
The group published the results of the first phase of their investigation in Molecular and Cellular Biochemistry in December. This phase was designed to determine how marine oil composition influences cardiac ventricular fatty acids and lipids or, simply put, how marine oils affect the structure and, ultimately, the function of the heart.
The researchers fed five groups of young guinea pigs different diets for four weeks. The groups were given either a standard, non-purified guinea pig diet (NP) or an NP diet supplemented with one of menhaden fish oil, harp seal oil, shark liver oil, or corn oil. While corn oil contains essentially no n-3 PUFA, it has a high fatty acids in the hearts, and concluded each of the oils has distinct effects on organ structure and on the production of biologically active metabolites in the heart.
Dr. Murphy says the findings from these studies actually make it more difficult to shed light on how seafood can promote healthy heart function. But the fact that it is healthy in our diets is definitely not in dispute.
Since the earlier Danish reports, large epidemiological studies have shown that eating one fatty-fish meal per week reduces mortality in people who have had a previous heart attack by almost 30 per cent, and that the same quantity of dietary fish reduces the risk of first-time heart attack by 50 per cent. Dr. Murphy says this makes fish oil more effective than antiarrhythmic drugs in preventing fatal heart attacks, with none of the adverse side effects.
Right now, the only source of concentrated marine oil fatty acids heartily approved by the Canadian government is fish. Concentrated and encapsulated oils are readily available in Europe, the United States, Japan, Australia, New Zealand and Chile. And in the U.S. (while it took the Food and Drug Administration almost 10 years), menhaden fish oil was recently approved for industrial-scale use in human food products.
Dr. Ackman says the Canadian government's reluctance to approve seal oil as a product may be due to competitive market forces. Seal oil would be in direct competition with flaxseed oil supplements, currently produced in western Canada, which provide vegetable oil omega-3 fatty acids.
Now in the next stage of research, the Physiology and Biophysics group is focusing more on how the different diets affect function. Dr. Murphy says the outcome of these studies will be of great interest to the scientific community. But with the surge in public interest on the issue of dietary fat, the results will likely grab the attention of nutrition watchdogs too.
|
 |
|
|
The average daily
consumption of seal oil by the Inuit
people is approximately 8-9 g, yet there
is very little information on the effect
of seal oil consumption on cardiovascular
disease risk factors. In this study,
19 healthy, normocholesterolemic subjects
consumed 20 g of encapsulated seal oil
containing eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA;
20:5n-3), docosahexaenoic acid (DHA;
22:6n-3), and docosapentaenoic acid
(DPA; 22:5n-3) or 20 g of vegetable
oil (control) per day for 42 days. Levels
of selected cardiovascular and thrombotic
risk factors as well as fatty acid profiles
of serum phospholipid and nonesterified
fatty acid (NEFA) were determined. EPA
levels in serum phospholipid and NEFA
increased by 4.3- and 2.7-fold, respectively,
in the seal oil supplemented group.
DHA levels rose 1.5- and 2.1-fold, respectively,
and DPA levels rose 0.5- and 0.7-fold,
respectively. Arachidonic acid (AA)
levels dropped by 26% in both serum
phospholipid and serum NEFA.
There
was a significant decrease in the ratio
of n-6 to n-3 fatty acids in serum phospholipid
from 7.2 to 2.1 and a significant increase
in the ratio of EPA/AA in NEFA. Ingestion
of seal oil raised the coagulant inhibitor,
protein C, values by 7% and decreased
plasma fibrinogen by 18%. No alterations
in other hemostatic variables, including
plasma activity of Factors VII, VIII,
IX, and X and antithrombin, or in the
concentrations of von Willebrand Factor,
total cholesterol, high-density lipoprotein
cholesterol, low-density lipoprotein cholesterol,
triglyceride, glucose, Apo A-1, or lipoprotein(a)
were observed in either group. Other risk
factors for cardiovascular disease, including
hematocrit, white blood cell count, plasma
viscosity, systolic and diastolic blood
pressures, heart rate, and platelet aggregation
after stimulation with ADP or collagen
did not change. Our results indicate that
seal oil supplementation in healthy, normocholesterolemic
subjects decreased the n-6/n-3 ratio and
increased EPA, DHA, and DPA and the ratio
of EPA/AA and DHA/AA in the serum phospholipid
and NEFA, while exhibiting a modest beneficial
effect on fibrinogen and protein C levels.
Fish
oils were used in medical research in
the USA and Europe, and thousands of medical
studies have shown that the EPA and DHA
of these oils have clinical benefits.
In that work, the DPA was ignored because
fish oil contains very little. However,
it has always been important in human
milk fatty acids, now an important research
area for DHA in connection with infant
brain development and the continued good
health of the mother. In ten thousand
years, human society has changed from
a hunting diet, emphasizing animals and
fish, to one dependent on large-scale
farming.
Our body
biochemistry, based on a model perfected
at least a million years ago, will take
thousands of generations to adapt to this
new lifestyle based on agriculture. The
so-called "essential" fatty
acids produced by farm products are of
a shorter chain length than the Omega-3
fatty acids of seal oil. Our bodies do
make the truly essential long-chain fatty
acids from the farm products, but slowly,
and the Omega-3 type may suffer from competition
from the excess of Omega-6 type in them.
It is time to go back to enriching the
diet of the entire family with all three
Omega-3 fatty acids. Seal oil provides
an easy solution to re-balancing our fatty
acid intake.
|
 |
|
|
Effect
of supplementation with dietary seal oil
on selected cardiovascular risk factors
and haemostatic variables in healthy male
subjects: Conquer JA, Cheryk LA, Chan
E, Gentry PA, Holub BJ.
Effect
of supplementation with dietary seal oil
on selected cardiovascular risk factors
and haemostatic variables in healthy male
subjects: Conquer JA, Cheryk LA, Chan
E, Gentry PA, Holub BJ.
Research projects on seal oil and seal
meat - results so far Results from a research
collaboration between National Institute
of Nutrition and Seafood Research (NIFES)
and Haukeland University Hospital (HUH)
indicate that seal oil ameliorate musculoskeletal
(joint) pain in patients with chronic
inflammatory diseases like inflammatory
bowel disease (IBD). The results so far
are promising, but larger controlled studies
are necessary in order to confirm these
results.
Background
The research collaboration on seal oil
between NIFES and HUS started in 1998.
Seal oil is extracted from the seals'
blubber and contains a high proportion
of the long chained polyunsaturated omega-3
fatty acids, similar to different kinds
of fish oil (approx. 20 %). Both refined
and unrefined oils from different seal
species have been used. All oils used
complied with legislation with respect
to content of undesirable substances.
Patients at the Institute of Gastroenterology,
HUH, suffering from gastrointestinal diseases
were the main target group in the research.
The seal
oil studies A pilot study, published in
2002(Arslan et al. 2002), examined the
effect of giving seal oil to 10 patients
suffering from inflammatory diseases (IBD,
chronic inflammatory disease, ulcerative
colitis, and Crohns disease) and joint
pain. When given seal oil (10 ml, 3 times
a day) for 10 days via a (nasoduodenal)
tube into the small intestine, the patients
reported an amelioration of their joint
pains. However, the intestinal symptoms
were only slightly improved. The treatment
was repeated for five of the patients
at a later stage, and they were examined
by a rheumatologist before and after the
treatment, confirming that the joint pain
was reduced.
The results
of Arslan's pilot study were confirmed
through a controlled study published in
2004 (Bjorkkjer et al. 2004). Here, 19
IBD patients with joint pain got the same
treatment with seal oil or soy oil for
10 days through a nasoduodenal tube, and
were followed up for 6 months after the
treatment by a rheumatologist. During
the study period the patients receiving
seal oil claimed improvement of their
joint pain compared to the patients given
soy oil. The effect of the seal oil lasted
up to several months after the treatment.
Analysis
of seal meat A study of nutrients in seal
blubber and seal meat was recently carried
out and published in Food Chemistry (Brunborg
et al. 2005). Seal blubber contains high
proportions of long chained unsaturated
omega- 3 fatty acids and mono unsaturated
fatty acids. Seal meat is lean (< 2
% fat) and is protein rich with a well
balanced amino acid composition. In addition,
it contains a high concentration of minerals,
especially iron. Seal meat has high levels
of vitamin A, D3 and B12.
More
studies are at various stages of publication
(revised version, submitted to be evaluated,
or in progress) and will be summarised
here when they are published.
More
information: Arslan G., Brunborg L.A.,
Froyland L., Brun J.G., Valen M., and
Berstad A. (2002). Effects of duodenal
seal oil administration in patients with
inflammatory bowel disease. Lipids 37,
935-940. Bjorkkjer T., Brunborg L.A.,
Arslan G., Lind R.A., Brun J.G., Valen
M., Klemetsen B., Berstad A., and Froyland
L. (2004). Reduced joint pain after short-term
duodenal administration of seal oil in
patients with inflammatory bowel disease:
Comparison with soy oil. Scand. J. Gastroenterol.
11, 1088-1094. Brunborg L.A., Julshamn
K., Nordtvedt R., and Froyland L. (2005).
Nutritional composition of blubber and
meat of hooded seal (Cystophora cristata)
and harp seal (Phagophilus groenlandicus)
from Greenland. Food Chemistry (Article
in press).
|
 |
|
|
Rheumatic
joint pain is a common extra-intestinal
complication of inflammatory bowel disease
(IBD). Because the high ratio of n-6 to
n-3 fatty acids (FAs) of the Western diet
might promote rheumatic disorders, we
sought to compare the effects of short-term
duodenal administration of n-3-rich seal
oil and n-6-rich soy oil on IBD-related
joint pain. METHODS: Nineteen patients
with IBD-related joint pain were included
in the study; 9 had Crohn disease and
10 had ulcerative colitis. Ten millilitres
seal oil (n = 10) or soy oil (n = 9) was
self-administered through a nasoduodenal
feeding tube 3 times daily for 10 days.
RESULTS: Compared with soy oil treatment,
seal oil significantly reduced the duration
of morning stiffness (P = 0.024), number
of tender joints (P = 0.035), intensity
of pain (P = 0.025) and the doctor's scoring
of rheumatic disease activity (P = 0.025)
at the end of the 10-day treatment period.
Analysis of the effects as area under
the curve (area between the curve and
baseline, zero) for the entire period
from start of treatment until 6 months'
post-treatment suggested a long-lasting
beneficial effect of seal oil administration
on joint pain, whereas soy oil tended
(not significantly) to aggravate the condition.
Consistently, the serum ratios of n-6
to n-3 FAs (P < 0.01) and arachidonic
acid to eicosapentaenoic acid (P <
0.01) were reduced after treatment with
seal oil. CONCLUSION: The results suggest
distinctive, differential prolonged effects
on IBD-related joint pain of short-term
duodenal administration of n-3-rich seal
oil (significant improvement) and n-6-rich
soy oil (tendency to exacerbation). |
 |
|
Effects on egg yolk
incorporation, stereospecific distribution
of omega-3 fatty acids, and sensory
aspects.
Seventy-two
26-wk-old Single Comb White Leghorn laying
hens were randomly assigned to 36 cages
(2 per cage) in a 3-orthogonal 4 x 4 latin
square, with the fourth row suppressed,
to assess the effect of feeding refined
seal blubber oil (SBO, containing 22.2%
omega-3 fatty acids) on the fatty acid
composition and position in the egg yolk
lipids. The experiment was conducted over
a period of 9 wk. Eggs were collected
and numbered, and the weights were recorded
for each week and cage.
Eggs
collected at wk 5 and 9 were used for
total lipid, lipid class, fatty acid,
and positional analyses. Sensory evaluation
was carried out on eggs collected at wk
6 and 7. Feeding SBO at 1.25% led to an
increase (P < 0.0001) in the long-chain
omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids (LCn3PUFA)
and a concomitant decrease (P < 0.0001)
in arachidonic acid (ARA) in the egg yolk
lipids. Yet this amount of SBO in the
diet had no effect (P > 0.1) on the
sensory attributes of the egg and on production
parameters such as egg weight, number
of eggs laid, and feed intake (P >
0.05). When feeding SBO in amounts higher
than 1.25% proportionately, a plateau
effect of the LCn3PUFA content of the
eggs was observed. This appears to be
because the PUFA content in the sn-2 position
of the phospholipids cannot exceed a certain
amount. When this amount is reached, the
LCn3PUFA will be increasingly stored in
triglycerides. The results presented here
clearly indicate how eggs can be produced
with optimized composition of LCn3PUFA
without affecting (P > 0.1) the sensory
properties of the eggs. The procedures
elaborated herein provide directly applicable
consequences for the food industry.
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
All
contents © Copyright 2006 NUTRICAN
|
|
|
|
|